Every homeowner reaches the move or improve question eventually. Often, it happens while standing in a kitchen that no longer works for the family living in it, wondering whether the money would be better spent changing the house or changing address.
There is no universal answer. But there is a better way to make the decision than relying on instinct alone.
It comes down to five key questions, and most homeowners only ask the first.
1. Is it the house, or is it the location?
Start here, because the answer can settle the move or improve debate surprisingly quickly.
If your house is too small but you love the street, local schools, neighbours and commute, improving your existing home deserves serious consideration. Those are things that can be difficult to replace.
If what you really want is a different area, a shorter commute or a completely different type of neighbourhood, no extension will solve the problem.
It is surprisingly easy to spend a significant amount of money trying to improve your way around a problem that was never really about the house.
2. What does moving actually cost?
The cost of moving house is easy to underestimate because it is spread across several different bills.
There is Stamp Duty Land Tax on the property you are buying, where applicable, which can be one of the biggest expenses. Then there are estate agency fees for selling your existing property, conveyancing costs, surveys, mortgage fees and potentially an early repayment charge on your current mortgage.
Add removals, storage and all those immediate expenses that tend to appear after moving, from decorating and flooring to blinds and furniture that suddenly does not fit.
There is also the process itself. Viewings, negotiations, uncertainty and potentially being part of a property chain all take time and energy.
None of this means moving is the wrong choice. It simply means you need to compare the full cost of moving with the full cost of improving, rather than looking only at the difference in property prices.
3. What does improving actually cost?
The cost of extending or renovating a home can be underestimated too, but for different reasons.
Homeowners often focus on the headline building quote without accounting for everything surrounding it.
There may be architect or designer fees, structural engineers, planning costs and Building Regulations approval. Then there is the build itself, plus a realistic contingency for unexpected costs.
Depending on the work involved, there may also be VAT, decorating, flooring, kitchens, bathrooms and landscaping to consider.
And then there is disruption.
Living through weeks or months of building work, potentially without a kitchen or with young children at home, has a cost even if it never appears on a spreadsheet.
Some households take it in their stride. Others find it extremely difficult. It is worth being realistic about which camp you are likely to fall into.
4. What is the ceiling price on your street?
This is one of the most important questions to ask before investing heavily in your current home.
Most streets and areas have a point beyond which buyers are unlikely to pay significantly more, regardless of how much has been spent on an individual property.
If you spend £80,000 extending a house in a road where comparable properties have never achieved the resulting value you would need, you may not recover all of that investment when you sell.
That does not necessarily make improving the wrong decision.
If you create a home that works brilliantly for your family for the next 15 years, the lifestyle benefit could make the expense worthwhile. But there is an important distinction between spending money to improve your quality of life and spending money expecting a financial return.
A local estate agent should be able to give you a realistic idea of your property’s current value, its potential value after improvements and the ceiling price for comparable homes nearby.
5. How long are you actually planning to stay?
Your timescale can completely change the move or improve calculation.
If you expect to stay for another 10 or 15 years, an extension that does not immediately recover its full cost may still represent excellent value. You are paying for many years of enjoying a home that works better for you.
If you think you could move within three years, the calculation looks very different.
You could pay the full cost of the work, live through the disruption, recover only some of your investment and then still face the costs associated with moving shortly afterwards.
So, how do you decide whether to move or improve?
Before making the decision, get two sets of real figures.
First, obtain a detailed builder’s quote for the work you actually want to undertake. Ideally, get more than one quote rather than relying on a rough estimate.
Then ask a local estate agent for an honest valuation of your property as it stands today and a realistic indication of what it could be worth once the work is completed.
Put those numbers alongside the total cost of moving, including Stamp Duty Land Tax where applicable and associated fees.
Once you are comparing real figures rather than estimates, the answer often becomes much clearer.
Want the numbers before you decide?
We are always happy to tell you what your home could be worth today, what it might be worth following improvements and where the ceiling price for your street currently sits.
There is no expectation that you need to sell. Plenty of homeowners we speak to ultimately decide to extend or renovate instead. We would simply rather you make the decision with useful local information in front of you.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to extend or move house?
It depends on the cost of the work, the costs associated with moving and the potential value of your home once the improvements are complete. The best approach is to obtain realistic quotes and valuations, then compare the complete costs of both options.
What is a ceiling price?
A ceiling price is the approximate maximum buyers are typically prepared to pay for a particular type of property in a specific street or area. Spending significantly beyond this point may mean you do not recover the full cost of improvements when you eventually sell.
What costs do people forget when moving?
Commonly overlooked moving costs include Stamp Duty Land Tax where applicable, estate agency and conveyancing fees, surveys, mortgage costs, early repayment charges, removals and immediate spending on the new property.
What costs do people forget when extending?
It is easy to overlook professional fees, planning and Building Regulations costs, contingencies, VAT where applicable, decorating, flooring, landscaping and other finishing work. The practical disruption of living through the project is also worth considering.
Does an extension always add value?
No. An extension can add value, but the increase is not guaranteed to match the amount spent. The type of work, local buyer demand and ceiling prices for comparable properties can all affect the eventual value.
If you know someone currently debating whether to move or improve, please share this guide with them.
Why we are proud to be an Ethical Agent
We belong to the Ethical Agent Network (EAN), a national group of independent estate agents that have passed an independent assessment covering honesty, service and community care.
Membership is earned rather than bought. When you see the EAN logo, it shows that the agent has chosen to be held accountable to the network’s standards.
If you would like to know more about the Ethical Agent Network, please get in touch.
Book a Valuation
Visit our Royston Facebook Page
Visit our Newmarket Facebook Page
View our Ware Facebook Page
